Read both!
Moloney basically admits much of his critique reflects a disagreement on journalistic first principles. While I'm more sympathetic to Moloney's understanding of journalism, I think Keefe explains most of his choices in ways that I find defensible. And Keefe explicitly addresses some of the general criticisms Moloney makes. I'm sometimes persuaded by Keefe's explanations, sometimes not, but I think he's more transparent about his perspective and his judgments are more carefully qualified than Moloney suggests.
But, as with most things, it would be a mistake to read only one book on the matter or to confuse journalism with history.
Complete thread:
- Pop Culture Resolution Suggestions -
Pat,
2020-01-03, 15:32
![[*]](themes/default/images/complete_thread.png "Open whole thread")
- Board games we like - Jamie, 2020-01-06, 09:44
- A few suggestions -
irishvol,
2020-01-06, 09:40
- Lost city was good
![[ [ No text ] ]](themes/default/images/no_text.png "Empty posting / no text")
-
Turtlecrack,
2020-01-07, 16:24
- Re: Memphis soul, the Stax-Volt Complete Singles (1959-1968) -
HCE,
2020-01-06, 10:03
- Great suggestion - irishvol, 2020-01-06, 11:17
- Lost city was good
- Just started a new Netflix series; 3 episodes in: excellent -
Ken Fowler,
2020-01-06, 05:33
- What an amazing premise. - Chris, 2020-01-06, 06:00
- Let the offseason posting begin... -
IrishGuard,
2020-01-05, 17:44
- There's a Cranium version of that game - BPH, 2020-01-06, 13:17
- Places to visit - Ski/Snowboard destinations - Mark, 2020-01-05, 19:05
- We need a few more movies and books - Pat, 2020-01-05, 11:43
- Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance -
irishted,
2020-01-05, 09:50
- Meet the Feebles cruel? -
IrishGuard,
2020-01-05, 10:33
- More like PG-13 cruelty. -
irishted,
2020-01-05, 10:47
- More like PG-13 cruelty.
- Meet the Feebles cruel?
- TV -
PAK,
2020-01-04, 14:44
- Second all of these - Pat (Moco), 2020-01-05, 06:05
- Podcasts! -
nedhead,
2020-01-04, 14:18
- Needed podcast suggestions thanks! -
Turtlecrack,
2020-01-04, 17:23
- Needed podcast suggestions thanks!
- Some ideas -
OGerry,
2020-01-04, 13:39
- Fuck yeah on hap and leonard -
Mike (bart),
2020-01-04, 14:48
- I tried to pepper the list - OGerry, 2020-01-05, 11:28
- Fuck yeah on hap and leonard
- My recs -
HullieAndMikes,
2020-01-04, 10:23
- Same here w/r/t Little Women. -
oviedoirish,
2020-01-04, 12:29
- Same here w/r/t Little Women.
- Thanks, but the last thing I need in my life is more -
Bill,
2020-01-03, 18:50
- Odd, you never struck me as much of an E! man, Bill -
KGB,
2020-01-04, 13:22
- broadly defined - Pat, 2020-01-03, 19:53
- Odd, you never struck me as much of an E! man, Bill
- Say Nothing, Patrick Keefe. -
Publicola,
2020-01-03, 17:59
- Say Anything, John Cusack -
Greg,
2020-01-04, 08:56
- Say Something, Just Timberlake -
Chris,
2020-01-04, 09:44
- Say what again. Jules Winfield -
hlewis,
2020-01-05, 08:33
- Say what again. Jules Winfield
- Say Something, Just Timberlake
- You might want to read Ed Moloney's review -
Bryan (IrishCavan),
2020-01-04, 06:30
- That’s interesting - HullieAndMikes, 2020-01-05, 04:59
- Read both! - Publicola, 2020-01-04, 08:13
- Whatever you say, say nothing - PasadenaDomer, 2020-01-03, 20:49
- Say Anything, John Cusack
- My reading list for the proverbial desert island: - HCE, 2020-01-03, 17:39
- I’m game -
Turtlecrack,
2020-01-03, 16:56
- Co-sign on Shadow of the Wind -
HCE,
2020-01-03, 17:43
- I missed that the third came out. Thanks! -
Turtlecrack,
2020-01-03, 22:54
- I missed that the third came out. Thanks!
- Co-sign on Shadow of the Wind -
HCE,
2020-01-03, 17:43
- jumping right in -
Pat,
2020-01-03, 15:51
- Saw Caamp here last week. - KGB, 2020-01-04, 13:33