A healthy dose of questioning recruiting site "expertise"

by Joe I , Thursday, March 26, 2026, 08:43 (6 days ago) @ BillyGoat

is warranted. As mentioned by others, looking at what other teams have offered seems to be far more predictive of a recruit's true upside.

Post reply

209 views

Complete thread:

'27 RB Lathan Whisenton commits to ND - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2026-03-25, 17:58
- FongBomb in for Isaiah Rogers 4* #9RB #146 Overall - Chris, 2026-03-27, 10:27
  - Lest I be labeled as a recruiting Debbie Downer, I will - BillyGoat, 2026-03-27, 10:36
    - How dare you sneer at MA high school football! - San Pedro, 2026-03-27, 11:21
    - Rogers + Whisenton - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2026-03-27, 11:09
- Tremendous name. - San Pedro, 2026-03-26, 07:13
  - 10.54 100m… same exact best 100m time as Jeremiyah Love - atxND, 2026-03-26, 09:53
    - That's a great sign. Speed kills. - San Pedro, 2026-03-26, 10:49
      - Can someone refresh my memory? - hobbs, 2026-03-26, 11:42
        
        He was definitely a burner and spoken of as such. - San Pedro, 2026-03-26, 13:25
        
        "Jitterbuggyness" - ReginaldVelJohnson, 2026-03-26, 20:56
        
        Heh. - San Pedro, 2026-03-27, 08:01
        
        Think he was seen as explosive - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2026-03-26, 11:54
        
        Thanks Men - hobbs, 2026-03-26, 15:20
        
        Exactly. Regarded as an elite athlete. I think some DCErs - BillyGoat, 2026-03-26, 12:06
- In to complain about 3 star - hobbs, 2026-03-25, 18:23
  - he's a composite 4*? - HumanRobot, 2026-03-26, 07:59
    - Carbon fiber? - San Pedro, 2026-03-26, 08:05
      - TimberTech - Chris, 2026-03-26, 08:06
        
        The great thing about this kid - San Pedro, 2026-03-26, 10:50
        
        Nice - Chris, 2026-03-26, 11:14
  - I generally agree. But in a year where we are putting - BillyGoat, 2026-03-26, 06:43
    - The staff appears to be pretty good at evaluating RBs. - omahadomer, 2026-03-26, 19:36
    - Why would pencilneck rankings take precedence - KGB, 2026-03-26, 12:33
      - Freeman has indeed been prone to permitting his - BillyGoat, 2026-03-26, 13:14
        
        There were two in the same class - BPH, 2026-03-26, 13:37
    - A healthy dose of questioning recruiting site "expertise" - Joe I, 2026-03-26, 08:43
      - Ahh, time for some BS, here’s mine - Mark, 2026-03-26, 11:25
    - Man, I thought you guys were joking - BPH, 2026-03-26, 08:29
      - It's funny. We all acknowledge DMC - hobbs, 2026-03-26, 08:54
    - I think its OK to grumble - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2026-03-26, 07:49
    - Bird in hand theory? - Domer99, 2026-03-26, 07:20
      - Not even close to the case - BPH, 2026-03-26, 08:31
        
        I agree he's talented enough to be the lead back in - BillyGoat, 2026-03-26, 09:38
        
        He had an OV set with Texas. - KGB, 2026-03-26, 16:34
        
        I think the best ND comparison of recent vintage - BPH, 2026-03-26, 10:47
        
        Admittedly I have been lax in following recruiting - Domer99, 2026-03-26, 08:34
    - No. It's early in the recruiting ranking cycle - hobbs, 2026-03-26, 07:15
      - Rivals says these also offered: - Grantland, 2026-03-26, 07:49
      - Is his profile as a RB as good as the DL and DB - BillyGoat, 2026-03-26, 07:29
      - Rivals own rankings have him 12th. - Chris, 2026-03-26, 07:18

the Polo Grounds

A healthy dose of questioning recruiting site "expertise"