do you think Maiava is any better than Carson Beck?

by Jay , San Diego, Tuesday, October 14, 2025, 10:18 (17 hours, 50 minutes ago) @ HumanRobot

Maiava's lofty QB rating (#3 nationally) is heavily weighted by Mo State and Ga South.

https://cfbstats.com/2025/player/657/1177721/passing/gamelog.html

Take out those cupcakes and his rating is around 162, which is top 20ish but not in the stratosphere. He's more in the CJ Bailey range.

(Also, look who checks in at #7, with nary a FCS opponent to pad the stats: https://cfbstats.com/2025/leader/national/player/split01/category02/sort02.html )

Post reply

163 views

Complete thread:

USC 2025 Preview - HumanRobot, 2025-10-14, 07:23
- To me, this game comes down to ND's run game. - Mark, 2025-10-14, 14:40
- do you think Maiava is any better than Carson Beck? - Jay, 2025-10-14, 10:18
  - Bailey's an interesting comp - HumanRobot, 2025-10-14, 12:26
  - Beck is way more battle tested at this point - HumanRobot, 2025-10-14, 10:33
    - Maiava also not much of a dual threat - Jay, 2025-10-14, 11:01
- nicely done - bpeters07, 2025-10-14, 09:44
  - also really great getting these on Tuesday - beattherush, 2025-10-14, 11:55
  - thanks - HumanRobot, 2025-10-14, 10:13
  - I also noticed and smirked at that - Savage, 2025-10-14, 10:10
- Some personnel stuff that I think helps us - Mike (bart), 2025-10-14, 09:43
  - thanks! - HumanRobot, 2025-10-14, 10:14
    - I think he wants you believe there's always something quick - Mike (bart), 2025-10-14, 10:19
- might be whistling past the graveyard - Jay, 2025-10-14, 09:09
  - I think our D at current level can generate a takeaway or 2 - beattherush, 2025-10-14, 11:50
  - Gollum was pretty unhappy with their defense - HumanRobot, 2025-10-14, 09:52
    - The post-Harbaugh fade is happening faster at UM - KGB, 2025-10-14, 09:59
      - Moore showed up to their presser - HumanRobot, 2025-10-14, 10:05
      - And they stopped knowing other team's plays - Mike (bart), 2025-10-14, 10:01
  - They tend to end their own drives, too - HumanRobot, 2025-10-14, 09:27
  - I think we can hold them to low 20s - BPH, 2025-10-14, 09:16
    - Agree on the RB. - KGB, 2025-10-14, 09:29
      - Little Lincoln Fauntleroy - lol - Jay, 2025-10-14, 09:54

the Polo Grounds

do you think Maiava is any better than Carson Beck?