Tradition is heavy
I like this traditional vs original church framework. I think Tradition vs. ____, is an informative way of looking at cultural movements.
Most people, most of the time crave tradition, a set of accepted, familiar rules that shape life. I love, or maybe am passionate about, all kinds of traditions, but gold helmets and the order of the mass are two.
The resonance between religious tradition and conservative reverence for government or conservative reverence for familiar power structures is easy. It's also easy to see how Tradition becomes a god. Something like critical reflection and continual rebirth is the necessary complement, and I work pretty hard on that.
It would be great if everyone worked as hard to critically appraise and take some distance from what's familiar, but I feel like we have to harness tradition as a cultural engine, because history seems to show you can't squash it without killing a solid chunk of people.
What else can you say as a Notre Dame partisan.
Complete thread:
- the most recent ND magazine, "domers in the news", p.57 - Jay, 2021-01-19, 11:18
- Sobering. And embarrassing. - San Pedro, 2021-01-19, 16:43
- I’m w/ you. I will NEVER get over it* - JD in Portland, 2021-01-19, 23:16
- I’m w/ you. I will NEVER get over it* - JD in Portland, 2021-01-19, 23:16
- Ugh, I had chicken patties same time as Schlapp, McGahn, and - Albie, 2021-01-19, 15:02
- Link, if you want to be e-depressed. - domer.mq, 2021-01-19, 12:28
- That's great - CW (Rakes), 2021-01-19, 12:39
- The last paragraph or so brings it back a little - MattG, 2021-01-19, 12:44
- How on earth does ND produce Matt Schlapp? - domer.mq, 2021-01-19, 12:46
- He's only a half step worse - Mark, 2021-01-19, 20:13
- We all knew a dozen proto-Schlapps by 1996 - MattG, 2021-01-19, 12:51
- Yeah, I'm '98, and OTOH I could tab a dozen guys - Brendan, 2021-01-19, 12:53
- There were some interesting things going on then - Domer99, 2021-01-19, 14:45
- I would have avoided his Masses, but not for *that* - Jack, 2021-01-19, 15:03
- it was a pretext* - Jay, 2021-01-19, 15:35
- it was a pretext* - Jay, 2021-01-19, 15:35
- I would have avoided his Masses, but not for *that* - Jack, 2021-01-19, 15:03
- So am I, and I'll bet that the list would have some overlap - MattG, 2021-01-19, 12:57
- Probably - Brendan, 2021-01-19, 13:08
- Tradition is heavy - Regular Joseph, 2021-01-19, 19:32
- Ok, but Matt Schlapp is just an outright fascist.* - domer.mq, 2021-01-19, 13:48
- Probably - Brendan, 2021-01-19, 13:08
- There were some interesting things going on then - Domer99, 2021-01-19, 14:45
- Yeah, I'm '98, and OTOH I could tab a dozen guys - Brendan, 2021-01-19, 12:53
- He's only a half step worse - Mark, 2021-01-19, 20:13
- How on earth does ND produce Matt Schlapp? - domer.mq, 2021-01-19, 12:46
- The last paragraph or so brings it back a little - MattG, 2021-01-19, 12:44
- That's great - CW (Rakes), 2021-01-19, 12:39
- At least 2 won't be in the news as much - Jack, 2021-01-19, 12:23
- Sobering. And embarrassing. - San Pedro, 2021-01-19, 16:43