I'm not saying we have it as easy as Georgia or Florida
I'm just saying that we actually have a nice building block there if we could nail it down. We could certainly do as well with in state talent as Wisconsin does, if not better. It'd be a great start, and I think we have done job, but should be a focus of improvement, I think
Complete thread:
- Some things to think about with this bowl game -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 06:18
- Anybody planning to travel for this? -
Mike (Max),
2017-12-05, 04:54
- I can help with some attractions -
oviedoirish,
2017-12-05, 06:08
- I am not particularly excited about the game - Mike (Max), 2017-12-05, 14:16
- I can help with some attractions -
oviedoirish,
2017-12-05, 06:08
- Pulling a couple of consensus points from this thread: -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 08:51
- What is the standard course load for an ND student -
oviedoirish,
2017-12-04, 12:14
- looking it up -
Jay,
2017-12-05, 09:02
- I always thought the standard was something like: - Grantland, 2017-12-05, 14:03
- 15ish is normal for most ND students. -
PAK,
2017-12-04, 13:33
- I thought it was normal for in season football players - Grantland, 2017-12-04, 14:39
- carrying 12 is the NCAA requirement - Jay, 2017-12-04, 13:57
- Depends on what they are doing -
DEM,
2017-12-04, 13:02
- I doubt I'd fit in seamlessly now either, - oviedoirish, 2017-12-04, 19:58
- looking it up -
Jay,
2017-12-05, 09:02
- Agree on all of those. - oviedoirish, 2017-12-04, 11:59
- other aspects where ND is at a competitive disadvantage -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:33
- Friendly amendment -
JD in Portland,
2017-12-04, 11:46
- just to be clear about my inclusion of "South Bend" -
Jay,
2017-12-05, 08:08
- But ND's relative whiteness - DEM, 2017-12-05, 13:28
- Isolated campus? -
mkmcfrlnd,
2017-12-04, 15:02
- Never been there; too dangerous - JD in Portland, 2017-12-04, 21:20
- Town is isolated. But college is the center of town. -
Greg,
2017-12-04, 16:38
- "Town" is all there is -
mkmcfrlnd,
2017-12-05, 05:06
- I think the notion that ND is in a worse spot -
KGB,
2017-12-05, 07:56
- I think we have a lot of aspects that favor us over... - Greg, 2017-12-05, 08:35
- we have some powerful competitive advantages too - Jay, 2017-12-05, 08:10
- I think the notion that ND is in a worse spot -
KGB,
2017-12-05, 07:56
- "Town" is all there is -
mkmcfrlnd,
2017-12-05, 05:06
- just to be clear about my inclusion of "South Bend" -
Jay,
2017-12-05, 08:08
- a couple more that come to mind, Alabama-style -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:53
- Back in the day, I believe - oviedoirish, 2017-12-04, 12:09
- How did each one of those -
Grantland,
2017-12-04, 09:40
- changes -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:58
- Have general demographics changed as well? -
Grantland,
2017-12-04, 10:06
- since the ND glory days, absolutely -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 10:10
- Interesting on the "Post War" title -
Jack,
2017-12-04, 11:36
- Mars Cheese Castle and Summerfest -
Albie,
2017-12-04, 11:41
- I think you nailed it. And don't forget supper clubs - Jack, 2017-12-04, 11:44
- Mars Cheese Castle and Summerfest -
Albie,
2017-12-04, 11:41
- Interesting on the "Post War" title -
Jack,
2017-12-04, 11:36
- since the ND glory days, absolutely -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 10:10
- ironically, we probably started the escalation of the TV$$$ - Grantland, 2017-12-04, 10:01
- Have general demographics changed as well? -
Grantland,
2017-12-04, 10:06
- The emergence of Stanford -
Jim (fisherj08),
2017-12-04, 09:56
- Which is why we really need to start beating them - BPH, 2017-12-04, 10:18
- changes -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:58
- I would dispute 1, 4, 10 and 12 -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 09:38
- bag men - Jay, 2017-12-04, 09:46
- Your point on talent in Indiana is incorrect. -
Jim (fisherj08),
2017-12-04, 09:42
- it punches above it's weight and is improving -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 09:54
- Take a look at the top 247 recruits here -
Jim (fisherj08),
2017-12-04, 09:57
- I'm not saying we have it as easy as Georgia or Florida -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 10:01
- We tried to get the best recruit in Indiana - Jim (fisherj08), 2017-12-04, 10:03
- It still probably only gets us 2-3 guys a year -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2017-12-04, 10:02
- 2-3 multi-year starters a year is a great base - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 10:08
- I'm not saying we have it as easy as Georgia or Florida -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 10:01
- Take a look at the top 247 recruits here -
Jim (fisherj08),
2017-12-04, 09:57
- The better argument for recruiting - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2017-12-04, 09:45
- it punches above it's weight and is improving -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 09:54
- the region is absolutely a competitive disadvantage -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:41
- for what? for talent? for coaching? -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 09:42
- recruits -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:43
- Even with our recruiting hits in the south and west -
KGB,
2017-12-04, 10:28
- travel is an underrated issue too -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 10:44
- Miami and Palo Alto in November. - Grantland, 2017-12-04, 11:20
- travel is an underrated issue too -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 10:44
- This is a few years old - CW (Rakes), 2017-12-04, 09:50
- Even with our recruiting hits in the south and west -
KGB,
2017-12-04, 10:28
- recruits -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:43
- for what? for talent? for coaching? -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 09:42
- Lack of a cooling glove - Greg, 2017-12-04, 09:38
- * Catholic/Non-Diverse student body - Grantland, 2017-12-04, 09:34
- Friendly amendment -
JD in Portland,
2017-12-04, 11:46
- Do you all think weather could be a contributing factor? -
Grantland,
2017-12-04, 09:24
- To steal from some HR theory - Brendan, 2017-12-04, 09:51
- I'd also like to see ND "recruit" grad transfers -
Jeff (BGS),
2017-12-04, 09:21
- Absolutely - BPH, 2017-12-04, 09:31
- Cody Riggs and Cam Smith seemed recruited - HullieAndMikes, 2017-12-04, 09:23
- I very much support a lighter course load in the fall - Jay, 2017-12-04, 09:07
- I do think easing the 4-year graduation requirement -
Bill,
2017-12-04, 09:02
- To my knowledge, they do not. - Slainte Joe, 2017-12-04, 09:31
- What is the standard course load for an ND student -
oviedoirish,
2017-12-04, 12:14
- This is the bowl game we earned -
CK08,
2017-12-04, 06:59
- Total agreement with this. - Greg, 2017-12-04, 07:18
- BK made mention of mental fatigue in his presser yesterday -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 06:50
- Dabo and Urban are masters -
Grantland,
2017-12-04, 07:32
- Well, Urban except for last year maybe -
Brendan,
2017-12-04, 07:58
- Think Dabo is clearly #3 right now -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2017-12-04, 08:51
- Agreed - Brendan, 2017-12-04, 09:54
- Think Dabo is clearly #3 right now -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2017-12-04, 08:51
- it's easier when you don't have to worry about class -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 07:48
- Rece Davis had a funny comment on Saturday - Jack, 2017-12-04, 08:04
- Don't buy this concept -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:52
- Isn't the most likely explanation... -
BPH,
2017-12-04, 08:48
- Almost certainly for any given year, yes - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 08:57
- responding to everyone -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 08:32
- On your analysis of November "good"/"bad"' years -
KGB,
2017-12-04, 08:49
- I am happy to hand off the research at this point - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 08:54
- As you said in Point 2 - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2017-12-04, 08:46
- Navy also gets to play bad teams late in the season -
Jim (fisherj08),
2017-12-04, 08:33
- as a wise man once said - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 08:42
- On your analysis of November "good"/"bad"' years -
KGB,
2017-12-04, 08:49
- Mike, go back and watch the NC State game - Greg, 2017-12-04, 08:28
- I know for a fact opposing coaches recruit on this concept. - domer.mq, 2017-12-04, 08:19
- Navy lost 5 of their last 6 games this year - HullieAndMikes, 2017-12-04, 08:16
- It's impossible to fail at Stanford and Northwestern is bad - Jim (fisherj08), 2017-12-04, 08:14
- I don't know if Stanford players worry about class. -
KGB,
2017-12-04, 08:14
- They can drop a class up to the day before the final -
Brendan,
2017-12-04, 08:30
- There's a parallel there to kids at the Naval Academy, too - Jim (fisherj08), 2017-12-04, 08:32
- Stanford has the reverse of our problem -
HullieAndMikes,
2017-12-04, 08:27
- they had a fireable loss early *this* season -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 08:29
- fireable where? -
BPH,
2017-12-04, 08:35
- oh I like what SDSU is doing - Jay, 2017-12-04, 08:58
- So was Tulsa in 2010 but people got plenty mad about that -
Jim (fisherj08),
2017-12-04, 08:36
- That's why I asked the question - BPH, 2017-12-04, 08:41
- fireable where? -
BPH,
2017-12-04, 08:35
- they had a fireable loss early *this* season -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 08:29
- They can drop a class up to the day before the final -
Brendan,
2017-12-04, 08:30
- Clemson and Ohio State were the examples -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 07:57
- Clemson's graduation rates, at least, are pretty strong. -
Kevin,
2017-12-04, 08:22
- so are Alabama's, now, after the light was shone on them -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 08:23
- Spot-checking their majors -
Kevin,
2017-12-04, 09:12
- What's the ND "football major?" -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2017-12-04, 09:15
- Seems like a lot were Psychology when I was there. - Grantland, 2017-12-04, 09:37
- Mack is FTT -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:36
- I'm guessing its sociology - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2017-12-04, 09:54
- I was wondering the same. -
Kevin,
2017-12-04, 09:32
- I don't think you can count business majors -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2017-12-04, 09:51
- As Norm McDonald would say, it's a double-edged sword - Kevin, 2017-12-04, 09:55
- I don't think you can count business majors -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2017-12-04, 09:51
- The best thing about a true liberal arts college like ND - HCE, 2017-12-04, 09:31
- What's the ND "football major?" -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2017-12-04, 09:15
- Right, graduation rate probably isn't a great metric - Jim (fisherj08), 2017-12-04, 08:27
- Spot-checking their majors -
Kevin,
2017-12-04, 09:12
- so are Alabama's, now, after the light was shone on them -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 08:23
- sorry, I misunderstood the point - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 08:04
- Clemson's graduation rates, at least, are pretty strong. -
Kevin,
2017-12-04, 08:22
- Isn't the most likely explanation... -
BPH,
2017-12-04, 08:48
- Well, Urban except for last year maybe -
Brendan,
2017-12-04, 07:58
- I think the "emotionally drained" part is right on the money -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:17
- But why? -
Slainte Joe,
2017-12-04, 07:32
- 11 USC/14 NCST/WAKE/7 MIA/NAVY/21 STAN -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 07:46
- Then I would characterize it as physical exhaustion. - Slainte Joe, 2017-12-04, 09:19
- We need to drop Navy. -
domer.mq,
2017-12-04, 08:01
- It would be a great start to our scheduling issues -
BPH,
2017-12-04, 08:32
- I do think there's a scheduling aspect to this - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 08:44
- It would be a great start to our scheduling issues -
BPH,
2017-12-04, 08:32
- my best guess would be because -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:36
- I didn't see any evidence of over-confidence this year -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 07:49
- not over-confidence so much as a bad mix of -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:56
- Here, let me just drag this out for you - KGB, 2017-12-04, 08:17
- come on Mike -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 08:02
- you call it what you want -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 08:20
- 1. I think you're amplifying what is a small sample size -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 08:54
- The easier conclusion -
Kevin,
2017-12-04, 09:15
- "We need more points!" — Mrs. Jay -
Slainte Joe,
2017-12-04, 09:21
- lol - Jay, 2017-12-04, 09:24
- "We need more points!" — Mrs. Jay -
Slainte Joe,
2017-12-04, 09:21
- it's a message board! -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 09:03
- good discussion -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:05
- We don't do audits until the Spring, right? - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 09:08
- good discussion -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 09:05
- The easier conclusion -
Kevin,
2017-12-04, 09:15
- 1. I think you're amplifying what is a small sample size -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 08:54
- you call it what you want -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 08:20
- not over-confidence so much as a bad mix of -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:56
- I think there were unique factors this year... -
BillyGoat,
2017-12-04, 07:47
- And we had to travel to opposite ends of the country in NOV - Grantland, 2017-12-04, 09:49
- The foot on the gas thing hurts when your depth isn't great - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2017-12-04, 08:59
- I think both things can be true - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 08:00
- I didn't see any evidence of over-confidence this year -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 07:49
- 11 USC/14 NCST/WAKE/7 MIA/NAVY/21 STAN -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 07:46
- also, to this point - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 07:23
- But why? -
Slainte Joe,
2017-12-04, 07:32
- Dabo and Urban are masters -
Grantland,
2017-12-04, 07:32
- Was LSU ranked before the Music City Bowl? I can't remember -
HullieAndMikes,
2017-12-04, 06:48
- Per Wikipedia: 22 in AP, 23 in Coaches, 23 in CFP - HCE, 2017-12-04, 07:52
- Good post. -
Buffalo,
2017-12-04, 06:44
- Agreed. -
Bill,
2017-12-04, 07:39
- 9-4 next season would be pretty good -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:43
- I think it would suck and be time to end the experiment. -
Bill,
2017-12-04, 07:45
- I initially took you to mean - Jay, 2017-12-04, 08:06
- Tough, but fair. - Buffalo, 2017-12-04, 07:52
- I mean, it was time to end the experiment a year ago -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:49
- The time to end the experiment was December 2009 -
Greg,
2017-12-04, 08:24
- don't Brinks truck me, bro -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 08:37
- I know, but... (not too long) -
Greg,
2017-12-04, 08:47
- no sweat, to be clear: I don't care much about championships - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 09:06
- I know, but... (not too long) -
Greg,
2017-12-04, 08:47
- don't Brinks truck me, bro -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 08:37
- The time to end the experiment was December 2009 -
Greg,
2017-12-04, 08:24
- I think it would suck and be time to end the experiment. -
Bill,
2017-12-04, 07:45
- 9-4 next season would be pretty good -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:43
- it's secretly a huge game - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 07:20
- It will influence me quite a bit, -
oviedoirish,
2017-12-04, 07:01
- Same here. -
Albie,
2017-12-04, 11:19
- I really bought into this team until the 2nd half of Wake. -
Bryan (IrishCavan),
2017-12-04, 11:22
- Yep, fully expecting a NC State Gator Bowl-like performance. - Albie, 2017-12-04, 12:27
- I really bought into this team until the 2nd half of Wake. -
Bryan (IrishCavan),
2017-12-04, 11:22
- Same here. - professor, 2017-12-04, 07:17
- Same here. -
Albie,
2017-12-04, 11:19
- I think we have a chance to finish in the top 10 with a win -
CK08,
2017-12-04, 06:57
- Agree. I hope that is the outcome! - Buffalo, 2017-12-04, 06:58
- Agreed. -
Bill,
2017-12-04, 07:39
- I have a couple of questions... -
Slainte Joe,
2017-12-04, 06:36
- Some numbers and a unifying theory -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:13
- I have a hard time with your theory. - Bill, 2017-12-04, 08:39
- Please explain how this only impacts ND. -
KGB,
2017-12-04, 08:19
- the working theory - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 08:28
- respectfully, I think that's bunk -
Jay,
2017-12-04, 07:52
- Agreed. -
San Pedro,
2017-12-04, 08:24
- these things aren't mutually exclusive - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 08:39
- We have 24 years of strong top-line evidence - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 07:54
- Agreed. -
San Pedro,
2017-12-04, 08:24
- I love this theory. -
Buffalo,
2017-12-04, 07:25
- yeah it's a sticky situation - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 07:34
- Certainly some. - Buffalo, 2017-12-04, 06:58
- Great point. I had similar issues in November. -
Albie,
2017-12-04, 06:48
- I agree. -
oviedoirish,
2017-12-04, 07:09
- We don't collapse in years where we lose games early - Mike (bart), 2017-12-04, 07:22
- I agree. -
oviedoirish,
2017-12-04, 07:09
- Some numbers and a unifying theory -
Mike (bart),
2017-12-04, 07:13
- Anybody planning to travel for this? -
Mike (Max),
2017-12-05, 04:54