I find it surprising.
Nobody would ever accept a white guy's dismissal of a claim of discrimination against black candidates as a simple "oh come on, don't mind the disproportionate numbers, we don't do that! Anyone who thinks we do is just looking to be a SJW victim.". But that seems to be the overwhelming tenor of the responses to discussion about the disturbing lack of political heterodoxy in academia and the "public intellectual" sphere, and it, by and large, goes unchallenged.
But I'd like to bow out now. I made my snark under the guise of the board rule to at least be funny (and I think it was actually a pretty good switcheroo, if perhaps predictable in its claim). And I accept your rebuttal that even though there are only like 3 notable conservative academic public intellectuals, there probably aren't tenure committees actively perusing donor rolls of R politicians as an exclusionary characteristic.
I do try not to argue politics in general, and especially not when I know that I'm against a side that is entrenched, as that'll just star bomb-throwing back and forth without any actual learning or consideration (introspective or extraspective). Besides, with the cross-board mudslinging and fanbase partitioning on the outrage du jour, I have better topics to waste my time with :)
Complete thread:
- The greatest moment in ND history -
JD in Portland,
2016-12-08, 20:38
- This is outstanding - Albie, 2016-12-10, 11:50
- Conservative student responds to watchlist -
Publicola,
2016-12-09, 08:42
- Either Duke has changed a lot very recently - JD in Portland, 2016-12-09, 09:30
- Ani Aprahamian representing -
Brendan,
2016-12-09, 08:24
- But the tell was that it was organic (i.e. commie) ice cream - JD in Portland, 2016-12-09, 17:23
- Wow, Jim Sterba still teaching at ND -
Jack,
2016-12-09, 07:17
- I had him as well - Publicola, 2016-12-09, 07:18
- That's awesome! - oviedoirish, 2016-12-09, 07:12
- 0 American Studies profs -
Mike (bart),
2016-12-09, 06:26
- Surprised a couple of them weren't on the blacklist already. - PMan, 2016-12-09, 07:14
- And note: 6 from the tiny though mighty PLS program. Boom! - JD in Portland, 2016-12-09, 07:01
- 1 from Theology -
IrishGuard,
2016-12-09, 06:46
- and I wish their were more from Business - only one. - Grantland, 2016-12-09, 06:48
- Sorry, Solidarity against a voiceless rant... is pointless -
KelleyCook,
2016-12-09, 05:32
- Has anyone attempted to blacklist you in your profession? - JD in Portland, 2016-12-09, 06:26
- It was not a voiceless rant -
Bryan (IrishCavan),
2016-12-09, 06:08
- Versus left-wingers stifling academic freedom on the right -
Savage,
2016-12-09, 18:47
- Yes, conservatives never get tenure. -
Publicola,
2016-12-09, 19:53
- Never? No. Rolling a boulder up hill? Yes. A Few Citations: -
Savage,
2016-12-09, 20:14
- Ah, yes, "studies" -
Publicola,
2016-12-09, 21:07
- I find it surprising. -
Savage,
2016-12-09, 22:18
- Fair enough. -
Publicola,
2016-12-10, 09:40
- Thanks for the followup! Solid discourse. -
Savage,
2016-12-10, 16:43
- fascinating discussion gents - Jay, 2016-12-10, 17:27
- Thanks for the followup! Solid discourse. -
Savage,
2016-12-10, 16:43
- Fair enough. -
Publicola,
2016-12-10, 09:40
- I find it surprising. -
Savage,
2016-12-09, 22:18
- Ah, yes, "studies" -
Publicola,
2016-12-09, 21:07
- Never? No. Rolling a boulder up hill? Yes. A Few Citations: -
Savage,
2016-12-09, 20:14
- Yes, conservatives never get tenure. -
Publicola,
2016-12-09, 19:53
- Amen. - PMan, 2016-12-09, 07:20
- Also, this comes on the heels of a big NYT write-up -
Publicola,
2016-12-09, 06:15
- Academia is the bogey man for the far right -
Bryan (IrishCavan),
2016-12-09, 06:31
- Straight from the Alinsky Playbook. -
Buck Mulligan,
2016-12-09, 13:08
- Definitely. The Tea Party's Rules for Patriots -
Bryan (IrishCavan),
2016-12-09, 13:18
- I guess you win this round, comrade. -
Buck Mulligan,
2016-12-09, 13:38
- верный - Bryan (IrishCavan), 2016-12-09, 14:05
- I guess you win this round, comrade. -
Buck Mulligan,
2016-12-09, 13:38
- Definitely. The Tea Party's Rules for Patriots -
Bryan (IrishCavan),
2016-12-09, 13:18
- Poli Sci leans to the right when compared to other - Publicola, 2016-12-09, 07:07
- Straight from the Alinsky Playbook. -
Buck Mulligan,
2016-12-09, 13:08
- Academia is the bogey man for the far right -
Bryan (IrishCavan),
2016-12-09, 06:31
- Versus left-wingers stifling academic freedom on the right -
Savage,
2016-12-09, 18:47
- The virality of ideas isn't proportional to page clicks - HullieAndMikes, 2016-12-09, 05:35
- Yes. My father was one of two triple Domers on ND's faculty -
Frank,
2016-12-09, 05:24
- Great story - NDTerp, 2016-12-09, 06:37
- Reason 2,456 why Fr Ted is my hero; great story Frank -
JD in Portland,
2016-12-09, 06:30
- Was thinking the exact same thing - Jack, 2016-12-09, 07:20
- Here, here - JN, 2016-12-08, 21:54
- Good stuff. - PMan, 2016-12-08, 21:36
- Amen. In the words of Billy Bragg, - HCE, 2016-12-08, 21:22
- i think they took a page out of Frank Thomas' book - DEM, 2016-12-08, 20:51
- fantastic and inspiring - Jay, 2016-12-08, 20:42