I thought in real-time that his knee hit before the reach

by Jeremy (WeIsND), Offices of Babip Pecota Vorp & Eckstein, Tuesday, October 21, 2014, 09:43 (3464 days ago) @ JN

They didn't really show too many replays of Robinson reaching immediately after.

In the days since, on review, it sure seems like the knee and the reach happen simultaneously.

locked

256 views

Complete thread:

So, let me get this straight. - professor, 2014-10-21, 08:38
- Prister had a breakdown of everything on the series - Domer99, 2014-10-21, 09:29
  - I completely missed the clock snafu - Jay, 2014-10-21, 09:35
    - Eh. He was down inbounds. - Dylan, 2014-10-21, 10:18
    - Me too. - BillyGoat, 2014-10-21, 09:36
  - On Robinson's catch - JN, 2014-10-21, 09:34
    - IIRC, it kind of doesn't matter. See video embedded. - Domer99, 2014-10-21, 09:49
      - Clock always stops on a first down - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2014-10-21, 09:58
        
        rewatched it. Not sure Prister is on the money here - Jay, 2014-10-21, 10:00
        
        Doesn't us taking the timeout with 20s on the play clock - PootND, 2014-10-21, 10:04
        
        That was my thought at the time - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2014-10-21, 10:24
        
        At the time, I thought we used the TO b/c - JN, 2014-10-21, 10:03
        
        makes sense - Jay, 2014-10-21, 10:06
        
        I know that. But does the official always wave both hands? - Domer99, 2014-10-21, 10:00
        
        Yes. - Greg, 2014-10-21, 10:02
        
        Thanks. That's the issue I was looking for clarity on. - Domer99, 2014-10-21, 10:07
        
        Right (and a small FU) - Greg, 2014-10-21, 10:12
        
        Hand signals are really important. - professor, 2014-10-21, 10:16
        
        reminded me of this - Jay, 2014-10-21, 11:38
        
        Yes, we actually have real hand signals for this one. - professor, 2014-10-21, 13:09
        
        This is great - bpeters07, 2014-10-21, 11:33
        
        Awesome. - BillyGoat, 2014-10-21, 11:32
    - I thought in real-time that his knee hit before the reach - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2014-10-21, 09:43
    - at the very least we're running the ball down there - Jay, 2014-10-21, 09:35
- On number three, if the penalty hadn't stood - KelleyCook, 2014-10-21, 09:17
- Here you go - bpeters07, 2014-10-21, 08:59
  - "Are you gonna call that?" - Dylan, 2014-10-21, 09:15
    - I can't tell if the nod and smile are in disbelief - JN, 2014-10-21, 09:24
      - He is thinking about hookers and champagne. - professor, 2014-10-21, 09:26
- You forgot: - PMan, 2014-10-21, 08:41
  - Added, thanks. - professor, 2014-10-21, 08:44
    - 15 yard OPI; marked off 16 yards. - PMan, 2014-10-21, 08:45
      - Right. Dammit. - professor, 2014-10-21, 08:49
        
        Helmet penalty would have put the ball at the 9, not 8 - Brendan, 2014-10-21, 09:16
        
        Well, if the penalty had been enforced properly... - ndroman21, 2014-10-21, 13:52
        
        Thanks. - professor, 2014-10-21, 09:19
- It was a 4th down play - JN, 2014-10-21, 08:41
  - Fixed, thanks. - professor, 2014-10-21, 08:44

the Polo Grounds

I thought in real-time that his knee hit before the reach