Correct. Speculation/spoilers inside.
But I think there's a lot more evidence in the text sprinkled here and there about who did it than there is for some of the other theories out there. It's closer to "Jon is the son of Lyanna and Rhaegar" (tons of evidence that point to this) rather than "Brandon Stark is Coldhands" (basically zero evidence aside from it sounding like a cool idea).
And by Brandon I mean Ned's brother Brandon, lost north of the Wall not Bran the warg!
Complete thread:
- OT: Watched Game of Thrones last night recorded. Holy Crap! -
GuinnessBob,
2014-04-15, 15:27
- Spoiler: the white walkers take over Westeros. -
nedhead,
2014-04-16, 06:33
- That would be like the mother of all "flipside" posts. - ReginaldVelJohnson, 2014-04-16, 08:01
- A certain poster decided -
Jim (fisherj08),
2014-04-15, 17:45
- I didn't tell you who did it! - NDTerp, 2014-04-15, 18:37
- Do you have a year to throw away ?... -
Mark,
2014-04-15, 15:55
- We don't really know for sure, do we? (spoilers) -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2014-04-15, 17:42
- "Widows Wail is not for cutting pies" -
MattG,
2014-04-15, 18:52
- GRRM writing all the Purple Wedding scenes was awesome. -
NDTerp,
2014-04-15, 19:49
- Sure seemed like it was meant to -
Jack,
2014-04-17, 07:29
- (spoilers) - NDTerp, 2014-04-17, 13:18
- The thing that the episode conveyed that the book didn't... -
PAK,
2014-04-17, 07:51
- For Sansa -
Mike (bart),
2014-04-17, 08:35
- He was brilliant in the part. - PAK, 2014-04-17, 08:38
- For Sansa -
Mike (bart),
2014-04-17, 08:35
- Sure seemed like it was meant to -
Jack,
2014-04-17, 07:29
- GRRM writing all the Purple Wedding scenes was awesome. -
NDTerp,
2014-04-15, 19:49
- It is. (spoilers) -
NDTerp,
2014-04-15, 18:40
- Loras* -
PBurns,
2014-04-16, 08:06
- In the show, it's Loras. (spoilers) -
NDTerp,
2014-04-16, 08:37
- (spoilers) - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2014-04-16, 08:39
- In the show, it's Loras. (spoilers) -
NDTerp,
2014-04-16, 08:37
- Loras* -
PBurns,
2014-04-16, 08:06
- Correct. Speculation/spoilers inside. -
PAK,
2014-04-15, 17:58
- You mean Benjen. -
NDTerp,
2014-04-15, 18:42
- Yeah, sorry. You're correct. - PAK, 2014-04-15, 21:13
- Agreed. - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2014-04-15, 18:01
- You mean Benjen. -
NDTerp,
2014-04-15, 18:42
- "Widows Wail is not for cutting pies" -
MattG,
2014-04-15, 18:52
- The rest of this season should be incredible.. -
mkmcfrlnd,
2014-04-15, 16:04
- I think I agree with you - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2014-04-15, 17:44
- It's going to be nuts. I'm not sure what you're referring to -
PAK,
2014-04-15, 17:33
- I think he's referring to (spoilers) -
NDTerp,
2014-04-15, 18:42
- Correct.. - mkmcfrlnd, 2014-04-16, 05:20
- It's silly how packed the book is. (spoilers obviously) -
PAK,
2014-04-15, 21:12
- The red viper is awesome. - Mark, 2014-04-16, 07:29
- One of the podcasts I listen to gave a nice word of caution: -
NDTerp,
2014-04-16, 06:42
- You can definitely tell there's some significant deviation -
Mark,
2014-04-16, 07:37
- Also books 4 and 5 are concurrent, not sequential - PBurns, 2014-04-16, 08:09
- Yes, but in that regard... - BillyGoat, 2014-04-16, 07:47
- Follow-up question... -
BillyGoat,
2014-04-16, 06:51
- (spoilers) -
NDTerp,
2014-04-16, 07:58
- (spoilers) -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2014-04-16, 08:37
- (spoilers) - NDTerp, 2014-04-16, 08:47
- Thanks. I ran out of gas at the end of Book 5 and - BillyGoat, 2014-04-16, 08:07
- (spoilers) -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2014-04-16, 08:37
- (spoilers) -
NDTerp,
2014-04-16, 07:58
- You can definitely tell there's some significant deviation -
Mark,
2014-04-16, 07:37
- I think we all know what the "final image" is going to be -- -
MattG,
2014-04-15, 18:53
- I'll probably get moist at that scene. -
NDTerp,
2014-04-15, 19:47
- Sploosh - PBurns, 2014-04-16, 08:16
- I'll probably get moist at that scene. -
NDTerp,
2014-04-15, 19:47
- I think he's referring to (spoilers) -
NDTerp,
2014-04-15, 18:42
- We don't really know for sure, do we? (spoilers) -
Jeremy (WeIsND),
2014-04-15, 17:42
- Spoiler: the white walkers take over Westeros. -
nedhead,
2014-04-16, 06:33