inspired by the LoVecchio/Rees discussion below

by Jay , San Diego, Monday, September 30, 2013, 14:37 (3854 days ago)

Rank the ND quarterbacks since the last championship:

Tony Rice
Rick Mirer
Kevin McDougal
Ron Powlus
Jarious Jackson
Arnaz Battle
Matt LoVecchio
Carlyle Holiday
Brady Quinn
Jimmy Clausen
Dayne Crist
Tommy Rees
Everett Golson

Tags:
quarterbacks

locked

1918 views

Complete thread:

inspired by the LoVecchio/Rees discussion below - Jay, 2013-09-30, 14:37
- most of these guys are mythological to me - HumanRobot, 2013-10-01, 07:15
- so Rees is about 10th or 11th by our estimation - Jay, 2013-10-01, 07:04
- McDougal uber alles - JPH, 2013-09-30, 18:25
  - I was thinking of rating him higher but he only had one year - Jack, 2013-10-01, 06:28
  - i agree with this - JD in Portland, 2013-09-30, 20:27
  - McDougal and Golson = one NC-level year each. - MattG, 2013-09-30, 18:47
    - In addition, wasn't that McDougal's only season? - Domer99, 2013-09-30, 20:27
    - there is one big difference though - JD in Portland, 2013-09-30, 20:25
      - Additionally... - KGB, 2013-10-01, 03:09
    - Two McDougal stats from the 93 season jump out at me. - San Pedro, 2013-09-30, 19:02
  - good stuff on McDougal - Jay, 2013-09-30, 18:31
- Here you go. - MattG, 2013-09-30, 18:19
- mine w/o looking - JD in Portland, 2013-09-30, 18:02
- Partial list because I have no respect for history - irishoutsider, 2013-09-30, 17:59
- Mine, without looking at anyone's. - Bingo, 2013-09-30, 17:36
- Mine - Bill, 2013-09-30, 16:14
- Mine, and I peeked at no one else's - Jack, 2013-09-30, 15:59
- Take Battle off - he only started two games - Spesh, 2013-09-30, 15:01
  - didn't he start the year with the job? - Jay, 2013-09-30, 15:22
    - Add Faila - he beat SC. - Glass, 2013-09-30, 16:01
    - Yep, broke his wrist/hand in the Nebraska game - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2013-09-30, 15:36
- My list. - Silk, 2013-09-30, 15:01
- Where's Double Disaster? - Ken Fowler, 2013-09-30, 14:55
  - Or Gary Godsey - hobbs, 2013-09-30, 15:00
    - I demand Eric Chappell - HullieAndMikes, 2013-09-30, 15:28
      - Bring me the head of Pat Dillingham. - KGB, 2013-09-30, 15:37
- On talent alone? Or with intangibles too? - HullieAndMikes, 2013-09-30, 14:53
- Assuming a Kelly spread type system - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2013-09-30, 14:51
  - I think Golson is way too low - BPH, 2013-09-30, 17:51
    - Needs more data - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2013-09-30, 18:04
      - How/why would you ever rank Powlus so high? - MattG, 2013-09-30, 18:22
        
        Yep, think I botched that - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2013-09-30, 19:06
  - Jarious Jackson in Kelly's system would be scary good. - Bingo, 2013-09-30, 17:38
  - Powlus > Quinn, eh? - Jay, 2013-09-30, 15:21
    - Yeah, that was a tough one - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2013-09-30, 15:35
      - see I thought Quinn was pretty good running the ball - Jay, 2013-09-30, 15:43
        
        I agree with you. - KGB, 2013-09-30, 16:00
        
        I remember two non-sneak runs from Brady - Jeremy (WeIsND), 2013-09-30, 15:49
        
        FTR: Career Rushing for ND QBs - DaveK, 2013-09-30, 17:37
        
        I remember Powlus running 2 options ever. - MattG, 2013-09-30, 16:09
        
        Oh, he ran more than that - Jack, 2013-10-01, 07:01
      - Wait. Powlus could run? - MattG, 2013-09-30, 15:43
- Hmmm - Dylan, 2013-09-30, 14:43
  - Move your parenthetical down one slot. - Glass, 2013-09-30, 15:52
    - Rice was great. Best option QB ever. - Dylan, 2013-09-30, 16:39
      - Mike Miller, Charles Stafford . . . - Glass, 2013-09-30, 17:17
    - Or put it next to Joe Theismann's name where it belongs - Jack, 2013-09-30, 16:02
      - I saw him at the Rock on Saturday - BPH, 2013-09-30, 17:53
      - Absolutely agree - DaveK, 2013-09-30, 17:43
  - Agree with most of this... - KGB, 2013-09-30, 15:41
- Very hard to do independent of system. - BillyGoat, 2013-09-30, 14:39
  - say it's Kelly as the HC - Jay, 2013-09-30, 14:40
    - Fair enough. Here... - BillyGoat, 2013-09-30, 16:34

the Polo Grounds

inspired by the LoVecchio/Rees discussion below