what's our no-show rate in the student section?

by Jay, San Diego, Friday, May 17, 2013, 08:55 (4771 days ago)

Interesting article here about Michigan's decision to go to GA seating due to 25% empty seats in the student section.

-----------

http://www.mlive.com/wolverines/index.ssf/2013/05/dave_brandon_student_attendanc.html


CHICAGO -- Some students are upset that Michigan implemented general admission seating for them at football games, replacing the old seniority-based assigned seating.
That includes the student body president, who said Thursday at a regents meeting that he's disappointed students weren't first consulted about the decision.

Athletic director Dave Brandon, though, continues to defend the move.

Brandon said this week that the department explored several ideas to spur student attendance, including additional marketing and the HAIL program. Not only did turnout not improve, it actually continued to fall.

While Michigan set another attendance record last season, it averaged 5,434 student no-shows per game -- a 25-percent absence rate. There was a 50-percent late arrival rate.

"We had a trend that was very alarming to us, and it got worse year after year after year," Brandon said during the Big Ten athletic director meetings in Chicago. "You go into the stadium and the team runs out of the tunnel, and you look up, and there's 7,000 empty seats -- or more -- in the student section.

"That's just unacceptable."

Brandon said he refuses to contract the student section because of the tradition for providing a ticket to every student who desires one. So he consulted with several other big-time schools to see how they handled seating, and discovered most of the biggest stadiums in the country feature GA seating for students.

He sought advice from some of them, including Oklahoma, Nebraska, Penn State and Michigan State, each of whom have had success with GA-style student seating.

"We tried to market our way out of the problem," Brandon said. "We had Denard Robinson doing appeals and Coach (Brady) Hoke doing appeals, and we were talking about it in the student newspaper, and we were going around campus and we were really trying to get people to understand how important this was.

"That's supposed to be the heartbeat of activity -- our student body. And not only could we not get an improvement, it continued to (decline)."

Michigan's announcement of the GA seating was met with immediate backlash from students. A pair of petitions appeared online, one garnering more than 3,000 signatures within just a couple hours.

The student president, Michael Proppe, told the school's Board of Regents on Thursday that he was "upset" the athletic department didn't consult students about the decision.

"The students are upset, to say the least. They feel that the athletic department broke its long-held social contract with the students," Proppe told the regents, later adding, "I wish the first step had been going to students and saying 'how can we get you to show up on time?'"

Brandon has said he did that for years, polling students around campus -- including players themselves -- in search of an impetus that would work.

But nothing did. So he and the athletic department settled on general admission seating -- a drastic change at Michigan, but one that has proven to work around the country.

"We'll see how it works, but we're hopeful that more of our students will show up before the game, to get the best seats," Brandon said. "Supply and demand oftentimes solves these things.

"If we're going to sell you a ticket at a substantial discount, we want you to be there. And hopefully, the changes we made will facilitate that. I don't think it'll solve the problem completely, but hopefully it'll start moving us in the right direction."

If they stopped scheduling games vs Asshole State U

by Pat (Moco), Bar, Urban Chophouse Short North, Friday, May 17, 2013, 12:41 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

and Delaware State and UMass and App State and teams of that nature, then maybe their students would show up to games.

Very low. Late, maybe, but very few no shows.

by ReginaldVelJohnson @, Friday, May 17, 2013, 12:27 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

I suspect our reasoning for going to GA had a lot to do with ushers simply getting tired of trying to kick people out of seats they shouldn't be in.

My impression was always that going to the game was expected. If you didn't go, there was something defective about your sensibilities. Plus, if you don't go, what else is there to do?

All that said, I did have one friend who didn't go to games (and didn't buy tickets). He was a huge football (and ND) fan, and it wasn't a money thing. He honestly just preferred to tailgate, then go back to the dorm and watch the game on TV.

I would also be interested to know how many of our Students

by Grantland, y'allywood, Friday, May 17, 2013, 11:57 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

(all fans for that matter) are there for the opening kick and stay until after the singing of the alma mater. All I have is anecdotal evidence, but I bet our numbers compared to most other BCS schools would further separate ND.

Very interesting. I didn't see ticket cost in the article.

by oviedoirish @, Oviedo, Florida, Friday, May 17, 2013, 11:34 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

Would UM students pay full GA price or still get a discount?

FWIW, here at UCF we have a different situation. We have a 45,000 seat stadium and 60,000 students. However, although attendance is getting better, our avg. attendance for non-big games is about 25,000. That's for everyone, not just students. Students can purchase a 6-game season ticket pkg for $60. But for many of the low attendance games, students get in free. For the games that are televised on a weeknight, faculty often get in free as well, to make the stadium look more full. For the games that sell out, there is a student lottery. Approximately 15,000 tickets are allocated for students, and I believe that the lottery winners get in free. If we continue to get better and do well in the "Big East" (whatever it's called now), then I'm sure tickets will become more expensive/harder to get for students (and everyone).

Last year: UM student tixs 6 games: $195 face + $10 fee

by KelleyCook @, Friday, May 17, 2013, 12:06 (4770 days ago) @ oviedoirish

- No text -

So that's what UM students paid

by oviedoirish @, Oviedo, Florida, Friday, May 17, 2013, 12:55 (4770 days ago) @ KelleyCook

to sit in the student section? That's about $35/game, which seems fairly steep for students. Wonder what they'll pay now?

What do ND students pay for football tickets now? When I was there it was free.

Half of face

by CK08, Friday, May 17, 2013, 12:56 (4770 days ago) @ oviedoirish

So between 35 and 47.50 per game, I guess.

Wow, I'm surprised it's that high.

by oviedoirish @, Oviedo, Florida, Friday, May 17, 2013, 20:28 (4770 days ago) @ CK08

Seems high anyway.

I'd guess its pretty low

by Rob (Rakes of Mallow), Chicago, Friday, May 17, 2013, 10:33 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

Only reasons 95% of the students wouldn't show up is if they're too drunk or get arrested for being too drunk.

The games around fall break may be lower -- likely due to freshmen moms not knowing that there are football games around that time and booking a flight ahead of time.

I would guess 2-3 percent undergrad, higher for grad (obvs)

by HullieAndMikes, Yelling at Sam Cane, Dunedin, Friday, May 17, 2013, 10:02 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

- No text -

I think there's a cultural aspect at play here

by Domer99, John Wesley Powell's Expedition Island, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:57 (4770 days ago) @ Jay
edited by Domer99, Friday, May 17, 2013, 10:28

Even the students who don't like football to begin with get caught up in it because everyone else embraces football. Michigan is an entirely different animal. It's a state university that has to pander to a lot of different constituencies, some of whom have little desire to attend football games.

Among BCS programs, I am going to guess that there isn't a larger student attendance ratio at any other school in America. Notre Dame allots 8.5 sections for the students (sections 28-36, http://www.und.com/facilities/nd-stadium-seating-chart.html ), which comprise 10,795 seats ( http://www.und.com/facilities/nd-stadium.html ). That's compared to an undergraduate enrollment of 8,371. That's nearly a 130% attendance rate using the undergrad enrollment as a measure.

Now, I realize that St. Mary's and graduate students are factored into the 10,795 number, so it's really not fair to claim such an attendance rate that actually exceeds the enrollment but it's an astounding number to think about.

It basically means that the students nearly universally embrace football as a part of the culture.

I realize I am getting a little off topic as the original question was about student turnout rates and arrival times. But I think the raw numbers kind of speak to the point tangentially if not anecdotally. Regardless of what people want to say about the changing composition of the student body, it still remains that the student body values football and shows up at a clip much higher than any other BCS program.

If you are saying Michigan has a Culture of Suckiness

by Jeff (BGS) @, A starter home in suburban Tempe, Friday, May 17, 2013, 12:02 (4770 days ago) @ Domer99

Then I agree

see what happens when you put in a jumbotron?

by Pat, in the cloud, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:46 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

- No text -

I'm sure all those B1GNetwork noon starts don't help much

by KelleyCook @, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:45 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

- No text -

just wait until the opponent is Rutgers or Maryland

by Pat, in the cloud, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:47 (4770 days ago) @ KelleyCook

- No text -

Soooo, basically their usual OOC crowd

by NDTex ⌂ @, Dallas, TX, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:50 (4770 days ago) @ Pat

- No text -

--
Extra Life | Twitch | Twitter |

Would love to see the game-by-game #s

by JN, Seattle, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:22 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

If you're telling me that UM can get 75% of their students with tix to watch Akron on a sunny September day, then I'm calling you a pig-faced liar.

From my unscientific visual survey

by Jack @, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:20 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

I'd be surprised if it's even 5%.

Even for the non-football fans, there is still the very strong social aspect of going to games at ND. And may it be ever thus.

Not that you asked, my theory on why student attendance is not as high at basketball games as it was when I was at ND, when student seats were sold out every year, is due to two factors, both important. One is obvious: we had great teams. But the second is that there are about 600 fewer men per class now than there were then. Just looking at my immediate family - I have three sisters who went to ND. One of the three is a sports fan. The other two wouldn't know if a football is pumped with air or stuffed with feathers despite not only attending ND but living in the same house as my dad and my brother - AND one of them marrying a fellow ND grad. Yet they didn't miss football games (well, one did, but that even amplifies the point). If either of them ever went to a basketball game in four years at ND, I'd be shocked. As for my daughter, same thing. She never missed a football game and wouldn't dream of it. She went to exactly one basketball game.

This is the "Marge has a gambling problem" ...

by Slainte Joe @, Raleigh, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:14 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

of all future ND-Michigan discussions I take part in.

"I call him Gamblor!"

by HullieAndMikes, Yelling at Sam Cane, Dunedin, Friday, May 17, 2013, 10:48 (4770 days ago) @ Slainte Joe

A quote upstaged in the same episode by the germs on Smithers' face telling Mr. Burns, "Freemasons rule the world!"

Anecdotally

by Jim (fisherj08) @, A Samoan kid's laptop, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:12 (4770 days ago) @ Jay

I can tell you that my younger brother, a rising senior at Michigan, is constantly frustrated by his friends who never bother to show up to games, because getting drunk is more fun. He only has two people who he goes to games with each and every week.

On the other hand (and maybe things have changed since I graduated in 2008?), going to football games was *the* most important thing in the world. Everyone shows up, because that's what is expected of you.

bc it's expected?

by JN, Seattle, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:19 (4770 days ago) @ Jim (fisherj08)

I thought everyone showed up bc they loved the team and the university. (You were talking about ND at the end there right?)

Read my above post alluding to that

by Jack @, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:24 (4770 days ago) @ JN

Women make up half the student body. There are a lot of women who couldn't care less about sports. No, really.

Yeah, a few men too. But they are more easily converted to the path of righteousness, though there are those who think The Big Bang Theory is a documentary series and are beyond hope.

But if you asked if they loved

by JN, Seattle, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:27 (4770 days ago) @ Jack

ND and the team, what would they say? While 18-22 on campus I'm guessing the vast majority of them would say yes.

I don't buy that a huge % of women are showing up at games solely bc it's expected of them. Esp 18-22 year olds experiencing independence mostly for the first time.

Putting it that way, I agree to an extent

by Jack @, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:30 (4770 days ago) @ JN

It's not because it's "expected of them". Everyone knows what football means at ND.

But at other schools (may be just about any other school), those who aren't interested in sports don't go to the games. The same goes for non-football sports at ND.

I plead guilty to that. I wasn't interested in hockey at ND. I went to one game in four years.

Also, there's nothing else to do

by CK08, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:58 (4770 days ago) @ Jack

On a home Saturday afternoon at ND, the only things to do are go to the game or study.

I'm sure at other schools there's a sizable contingent that watches the game on TV while drinking.

Part of it is that ND guarantees tickets to every student that wants them. If you're at a big school and only half your friends manage to get tickets, you might just keep drinking and watch on TV at least some of the weeks.

Yup

by JN, Seattle, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:34 (4770 days ago) @ Jack

And I like hockey well enough and had a great time at the one game I attended but I only attended one game. Part of it is schedule. If ND had a bunch of weekday evening football games I wouldn't have had a perfect attendance record.

Social pressure is a powerful thing.

by Jim (fisherj08) @, A Samoan kid's laptop, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:29 (4770 days ago) @ JN

If I'm at a tailgate, and every one of my friends says "we're going to the game, stop drinking!", I will probably follow them into the game.

If I'm at a tailgate, and my friends say "let's keep drinking, who cares about football!", I'm going to stay outside.

I don't doubt that the folks in the second possibility love the University of Michigan, and I don't doubt that they love their football team. It's an issue of prioritization.

And it's nudged along by the campus rules

by Jack @, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:33 (4770 days ago) @ Jim (fisherj08)

Which were put in place a some years ago, IIRC just before your time, that tailgating during the game by students was declared streng verboten.

Before that there was a large group of students who continued to tailgate in front of Legends (or rather, Senior Bar at the time) during the game.

Guaranteed there is no such rule for students at Michigan. It's likely unenforceable there even if there were.

I'm confused

by JN, Seattle, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:33 (4770 days ago) @ Jim (fisherj08)

Are we talking about ND or UM? My comments are ND specific and I have no idea if they'd apply at UM but I wouldn't be surprised at all if they didn't.

What I'm saying

by Jim (fisherj08) @, A Samoan kid's laptop, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:35 (4770 days ago) @ JN

is that every student at every university loves their football team.

At Notre Dame, however, there's additional societal pressure to actually show up to games. That doesn't exist everywhere-and it's part of what makes the Notre Dame student body special!

I disagree with your premise

by JN, Seattle, Friday, May 17, 2013, 10:44 (4770 days ago) @ Jim (fisherj08)

I think the % of students that love their football team at ND is significantly higher than most schools. I only have my experience at one other private Midwest school and some close association with the U of Iowa to go on. But Iowa fans are generally considered among the most loyal in cfb and yet the % of students with no interest in football dwarfs that number at ND. Appears to be the same at UM.

When you're dealing with huge public universities and a much smaller private school that has the richest football tradition in all of cfb, it's not a fair comparison.

Even people who aren't overly invested in football

by Jim (fisherj08) @, A Samoan kid's laptop, Friday, May 17, 2013, 09:21 (4770 days ago) @ JN

still show up to the games.

powered by my little forum